Back to OH
Kelleys Island
Erie County, OH
AVOIDLegal
STR Opportunity Score
54
/100
📈Demand
80
💰Affordability
55
📋Regulation
80
🌤️Seasonality
65
📊Saturation
42
Will This Deal Work?
Money You Make vs. Price You Pay
F
BAD DEAL
RPR: 10.9%
Can You Pay the Bills?
✗
Risky
May struggle with payments
THE BOTTOM LINE ❌
Skip this one. You might struggle to cover your expenses.
💵
$265
Avg ADR
📅
45%
Occupancy
💰
$3,578
Monthly Revenue
🏠
$395K
Median Price
📊 Income by Property Size
Monthly revenue estimates by bedroom count
1BR
$1,431
2BR
$2,505
3BR
$3,578
4BR
$5,009
5BR
$6,083
6BR+
$7,156
⭐ Best
🏠 Top Amenities for This Market
Add these to boost your revenue
MUST HAVEBoat Dock
+28%MUST HAVELake Views
+18%HIGH IMPACTKayaks/Canoes
+12%HIGH IMPACTFire Pit
+10%NICE TO HAVEHot Tub
+15%📈 Market Saturation
Competition LevelHIGH
High competition - focus on unique amenities to stand out.
🎯 Your Next Steps
1
Search for 6BR+ properties
Best income potential at $7,156/month
2
Add a Boat Dock
Boost revenue by +28%
3
Target $4,473/month
Top 25% performer income goal
📋 Regulation Status
Legal
Short-term rentals are allowed in this area. Always verify local ordinances before purchasing.