Back to NY

Buffalo

Erie County, NY

STR Investment Grade

Transparent Scoring
C
54/100
⚠️ CAUTION
Score Breakdown
💰Cash-on-Cash
30/35
🏠Affordability
18/25
📅Year-Round Income
9/15
🤝Landlord Friendly
2/10
📈Room to Grow
3/15
Cash-on-Cash
18.9%
Excellent (15%+)
Median Home
$230K
Affordable
Room to Grow
3/15
Crowded Market
⚠️

STR Regulations Apply

Registration required; zoning restrictions

Buffalo requires STR registration and compliance with zoning. Some residential zones restrict non-owner-occupied rentals.

Permit: Moderate
Grade Impact: Base score of 62/100 would be grade B, but capped at C (54/100) due to regulation risk.
Verified data as of February 2026 · Regulations change frequently
📞 How to Verify
Call the Buffalo City Clerk or Planning & Zoning Department and ask:
1. Are short-term rentals (under 30 days) allowed at [your address]?
2. What permits or licenses are required?
3. Are there owner-occupancy requirements?
4. Any caps on rental nights per year or number of permits?
Many cities have active short-term rentals operating legally with permits — restrictions don't always mean it's impossible.

Why Buffalo?

Rural Market

What drives short-term rental demand here

🌾
Rural & Country Market

Privacy seekers and remote workers fuel growing demand for secluded, nature-adjacent stays.

🔥
High Demand Zone

Strong traveler demand supports a competitive market with proven revenue potential.

Will This Deal Work?

Investment Grade
C
Excellent (15%+)
CoC: 18.9%
Can You Pay the Bills?
YES
Income covers mortgage
THE BOTTOM LINE ⚠️

This market has STR regulations to be aware of. Many hosts operate successfully with proper permits. Research local ordinances before committing.

💵
$203
Avg ADR
📅
52%
Occupancy
💰
$3,167
Monthly Revenue
🏠
$230K
Median Price

Market estimates · Updated Feb 2026

📊 Income by Property Size

Monthly revenue estimates by bedroom count

1BR
$1,742
2BR
$2,375
3BR
$3,167
4BR
$4,275
5BR
$5,226
6BR+
$6,176
⭐ Best

🏠 Top Amenities for This Market

Add these to boost your revenue

MUST HAVEHot Tub
+20%
HIGH IMPACTFire Pit
+12%
HIGH IMPACTPrivacy/Seclusion
+15%
HIGH IMPACTOutdoor Space
+10%
NICE TO HAVEGame Room
+14%

🎯 Your Next Steps

1
Search for 6BR+ properties
Best income potential at $6,176/month
2
Add a Hot Tub
Boost revenue by +20%
3
Target $3,959/month
Top 25% performer income goal

📋 Regulation Status

RegulatedPermit: ModerateVerified Data

Regulations vary by city and county. Always verify local STR ordinances, permit requirements, and zoning laws before purchasing.

Research Comparable Listings

See active short-term rentals in this market

View Listings on Airbnb

Opens Airbnb.com in a new tab to view real listings and pricing in this market

Take the Next Step

Find homes, agents, and lenders in this market

Opens Zillow.com in a new tab

Want Jeff's Team to Help You Close?

Our coaching students get matched with vetted agents and STR-friendly lenders

Learn More
📊

Run the Numbers on a Property

Free STR calculator with comp data for any address

Ready to Invest?

See how our students earn $2K–$4K/mo from rural Airbnbs — even as first-time investors.

Apply Now

Buffalo, New York is rated C for Airbnb investment with a score of 54/100 (CAUTION). The market has an average daily rate (ADR) of $203, 52% occupancy, and estimated monthly STR revenue of $3,167. Median home value is $229,957 with a cash-on-cash return of 18.9%. STR regulation status: Regulated. Data powered by Edge by Teeco using estimated market data.