Back to Map
New York
BUYSTR Rules →
State Investment Grade
Based on city averagesA
78/100
BUY
Market Grade Distribution
A
8 (16%)
B+
3 (6%)
B
6 (12%)
C
8 (16%)
D
16 (31%)
F
10 (20%)
State grade is based on the top-performing cities in the state. Adding more markets won't lower the grade — it only improves when quality cities are added.
Market estimates · Updated Feb 2026
Sort by
Filter
51 markets found
Montour Falls
Schuyler County
A
83
Score
ADR
$318
Occupancy
46%
Monthly
$4,393
Price
$198K
View
Lansing
Tompkins County
A
83
Score
ADR
$203
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,167
Price
$195K
View
Dunkirk
Chautauqua County
A
82
Score
ADR
$330
Occupancy
43%
Monthly
$4,253
Price
$127K
View
Colton
St. Lawrence County
A
79
Score
ADR
$335
Occupancy
37%
Monthly
$3,721
Price
$175K
View
Wolcott
Wayne County
A
79
Score
ADR
$432
Occupancy
36%
Monthly
$4,666
Price
$198K
View
Geneva
Ontario County
A
79
Score
ADR
$203
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,167
Price
$210K
View
Watkins Glen
Schuyler County
A
79
Score
ADR
$216
Occupancy
58%
Monthly
$3,750
Price
$224K
View
Cassadaga
Chautauqua County
A
76
Score
ADR
$533
Occupancy
30%
Monthly
$4,796
Price
$166K
View
Hunter
Greene County
B+
69
Score
ADR
$175
Occupancy
68%
Monthly
$3,570
Price
$295K
View
Canandaigua
Ontario County
B+
68
Score
ADR
$242
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$4,000
Price
$285K
View
Syracuse
Onondaga County
B+
67
Score
ADR
$194
Occupancy
50%
Monthly
$2,917
Price
$202K
View
Old Forge
Herkimer County
B
63
Score
ADR
$213
Occupancy
50%
Monthly
$3,195
Price
$261K
View
Rochester
Olmsted County
B
62
Score
ADR
$200
Occupancy
50%
Monthly
$3,000
Price
$225K
View
Dresden
Yates County
B
62
Score
ADR
$198
Occupancy
45%
Monthly
$2,667
Price
$217K
View
Lake Placid
Essex County
B
59
Score
ADR
$295
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$4,602
Price
$352K
View
Dundee
Yates County
B
56
Score
ADR
$197
Occupancy
48%
Monthly
$2,833
Price
$279K
View
Tupper Lake
Franklin County
B
56
Score
ADR
$197
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,073
Price
$278K
View
Buffalo
Erie County
C
54
Score
ADR
$203
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,167
Price
$230K
View
Hammondsport
Steuben County
C
54
Score
ADR
$216
Occupancy
54%
Monthly
$3,500
Price
$311K
View
Finger Lakes
Seneca County
C
51
Score
ADR
$225
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,510
Price
$295K
View
Trumansburg
Tompkins County
C
50
Score
ADR
$217
Occupancy
50%
Monthly
$3,250
Price
$323K
View
Phoenicia
Ulster County
C
50
Score
ADR
$238
Occupancy
54%
Monthly
$3,856
Price
$384K
View
Albany
Albany County
C
45
Score
ADR
$224
Occupancy
52%
Monthly
$3,500
Price
$310K
View
Windham
Greene County
C
45
Score
ADR
$207
Occupancy
56%
Monthly
$3,478
Price
$374K
View
Inlet
Hamilton County
C
45
Score
ADR
$163
Occupancy
45%
Monthly
$2,200
Price
$262K
View
New York City
New York County
D
41
Score
ADR
$285
Occupancy
82%
Monthly
$7,011
Price
$805K
View
Rhinebeck
Dutchess County
D
41
Score
ADR
$298
Occupancy
62%
Monthly
$5,542
Price
$616K
View
Skaneateles
Onondaga County
D
41
Score
ADR
$240
Occupancy
56%
Monthly
$4,032
Price
$465K
View
Tannersville
Greene County
D
40
Score
ADR
$194
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$3,201
Price
$393K
View
Shelter Island
Suffolk County
D
39
Score
ADR
$440
Occupancy
69%
Monthly
$9,107
Price
$1723K
View
Penn Yan
Yates County
D
39
Score
ADR
$208
Occupancy
48%
Monthly
$3,000
Price
$313K
View
Saugerties
Ulster County
D
38
Score
ADR
$222
Occupancy
62%
Monthly
$4,129
Price
$462K
View
Fire Island
Suffolk County
D
38
Score
ADR
$395
Occupancy
61%
Monthly
$7,228
Price
$776K
View
Catskills Region
Ulster County
D
37
Score
ADR
$285
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$4,703
Price
$425K
View
Cooperstown
Otsego County
D
37
Score
ADR
$160
Occupancy
60%
Monthly
$2,880
Price
$366K
View
Lake George
Warren County
D
36
Score
ADR
$205
Occupancy
62%
Monthly
$3,813
Price
$516K
View
Sag Harbor
Suffolk County
D
36
Score
ADR
$450
Occupancy
58%
Monthly
$7,830
Price
$2163K
View
Bolton Landing
Warren County
D
36
Score
ADR
$240
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$3,960
Price
$723K
View
Amagansett
Suffolk County
D
36
Score
ADR
$360
Occupancy
63%
Monthly
$6,804
Price
$2966K
View
Yonkers
Westchester County
D
36
Score
ADR
$209
Occupancy
76%
Monthly
$4,765
Price
$671K
View
New Rochelle
Westchester County
D
36
Score
ADR
$190
Occupancy
58%
Monthly
$3,306
Price
$895K
View
Woodstock
Ulster County
F
34
Score
ADR
$205
Occupancy
58%
Monthly
$3,567
Price
$425K
View
Saratoga Springs
Saratoga County
F
33
Score
ADR
$185
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$3,052
Price
$611K
View
Saranac Lake
Franklin County
F
33
Score
ADR
$166
Occupancy
59%
Monthly
$2,938
Price
$313K
View
Cold Spring
Putnam County
F
33
Score
ADR
$241
Occupancy
48%
Monthly
$3,470
Price
$689K
View
Montauk
Suffolk County
F
33
Score
ADR
$450
Occupancy
59%
Monthly
$7,965
Price
$1937K
View
Greenport
Suffolk County
F
33
Score
ADR
$290
Occupancy
60%
Monthly
$5,220
Price
$958K
View
Beacon
Dutchess County
F
32
Score
ADR
$205
Occupancy
72%
Monthly
$4,428
Price
$525K
View
Ithaca
Tompkins County
F
28
Score
ADR
$165
Occupancy
55%
Monthly
$2,722
Price
$345K
View
New York
New York County
F
27
Score
ADR
$171
Occupancy
76%
Monthly
$3,899
Price
$805K
View
Hudson
Columbia County
F
26
Score
ADR
$272
Occupancy
47%
Monthly
$3,835
Price
$420K
View
New York is rated A for Airbnb investment (BUY) with 51 tracked STR markets. The state averages $275/night ADR and $498,438 median home value, with 4.2% annual appreciation. Net domestic migration: -580,000 residents/year.Top-graded cities include Dunkirk, Montour Falls, Colton.Data powered by Edge by Teeco using estimated market data.